California's Answer to FERC on Data Centers: No Bring-Your-Own-Generation Rule, and the Utilities Write the Cost Terms
In FERC Docket ER27-532, the California ISO defines a 50 MW large load, offers interim flexible hookups and declines a generation-matching requirement. PG&E and SCE, in their own filings, set a 15-year minimum revenue floor with five years of security.
| Item | Body | Load | Stage | Src |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CAISO large load tariff: 50 MW definition, FILI interim flexible service, co-location disclosure, no generation-matching requirement | FERC Docket ER27-532 (CAISO) | 50 MW or greater peak load | filed Nov. 16, 2026; effective date requested Feb. 16, 2027 | [1] |
| Original CAISO filing under compliance code | FERC Docket ER27-506 (CAISO) | — | amended and withdrawn Nov. 18, 2026 | [2] |
| PG&E large load interconnection process and Cost Assurance Agreement (minimum annual revenue, 5-year security, exit fee) | FERC Docket ER27-513 (PG&E) | — | filed Nov. 16, 2026; comments due Dec. 7, 2026 | [5] |
| SCE large load interconnection procedures, upgrade security and minimum annual revenue obligation | FERC Docket ER27-508 (SCE) | — | filed Nov. 16, 2026; comments due Dec. 7, 2026 | [6] |
“At this time, a bring-your-own generation requirement is not a condition for interconnection or transmission service.” That sentence, from the California Independent System Operator’s November 16 filing at FERC, Docket ER27-532, is where California parts from the eastern grid operators [1]. CAISO’s answer to FERC’s June 18 large-load show cause order, Docket EL26-71, defines a large load, adds a flexible interim hookup and leaves most of the money questions to the utilities that own the wires [1]. Those utilities filed their own terms the same day [5,6].
CAISO cites a California Energy Commission forecast of 1.8 GW of added data center load on its grid by 2030 and 4.7 GW by 2035 [1]. PG&E quotes the same 2030 figure and 4.9 GW by 2040 [5]. Both are forecasts, not queues.
What CAISO filed, and in which docket
The filing first went in as ER27-506 under a compliance filing code. CAISO calls that a “clerical error,” refiled the identical tariff records as ER27-532 under the code for a new Section 205 proceeding, and on November 18 amended and withdrew the first docket [2]. FERC’s notice sets comments on ER27-532 for 5 p.m. Eastern on December 16, 2026 [3].
The operative pieces:
- Definition. A Large Load is “An End User located at a single site behind one or more points of interconnection to the CAISO Controlled Grid, and that has a peak load of 50 MW or greater” [1]. Unlike FERC’s suggested wording, it drops the voltage test, the “commercial or industrial” label and the exclusion for co-located load [1].
- Grandfathering. Loads that are operating, or that have a complete request at the utility before February 16, 2027, are not large loads unless they later expand [1].
- Who studies. The participating transmission owners (PTOs) keep the load interconnection studies; CAISO reviews them and can flag any utility fix it considers a reliability risk [1].
- Data and operations. Before energization the utility must give CAISO the load’s operating profile, ramping and curtailment ability and any behind-the-meter generation, and the load may not ramp faster than 20 MW per minute on a rolling 10-minute average [1].
- Co-location. Generator interconnection customers must disclose planned co-located load, meaning load wired to the plant’s site [1].
CAISO asks for a February 16, 2027 effective date, with scheduling coordinator rules on November 1, 2027 and settlement changes on April 30, 2028 [1].
Why there is no generation-matching rule
CAISO’s case is structural. It has no centralized forward capacity market; supply comes through state forecasting, integrated resource planning and the resource adequacy duties of each load-serving entity [1]. Generation-linked mechanisms elsewhere, it argues, solve “a constraint that the CAISO’s framework does not impose” [1]. As this column noted on November 19, New York’s version sorts loads by their effect on resource adequacy and sends the rest to non-firm service. CAISO does not.
It also declines to change how behind-the-meter generation is netted. PJM bills transmission on peak demand, so a load could hide its use by generating at the peak; CAISO bills access charges on gross load around the clock, so “any energy withdrawal by the large load will be reflected in the gross load,” it writes [1]. Co-located loads will be sub-metered so they pay regulation and black start charges on gross load [1].
What it does to cost and timing
For timing, CAISO offers Flexible Interim Load Interconnection (FILI): a load energizes before its network upgrades are finished, under a three-party agreement that sets when and how it is curtailed, then moves to firm service [1]. CAISO declines “any kind of temporal or capacity cap” on FILI and says it will post the agreements [1]. A permanent version, which could let a curtailable load skip some upgrades altogether, is planned for a 2027 stakeholder process [1].
For cost, CAISO proposes no “top-down” allocation of its own [1]. The terms are in the utilities’ tariffs. PG&E’s, in ER27-513:
- Study entry. A $500,000 cash deposit plus $1,000 per MW of requested load in security [5].
- Upgrades built for the load. The customer pays up front, then gets refunds of 75% of the wholesale transmission revenue its load actually produces, for up to 15 years [5]. PG&E ties the 75% to SB 886, signed September 21, 2026 [5]. A load that comes in small “may never recoup its full costs” [5].
- Shared reliability upgrades. A Cost Assurance Agreement sets a Minimum Annual Revenue Obligation: scheduled megawatts × hours in the year × 80% × 75% × the CAISO access charge [5]. The schedule must reach the full requested capacity by Year 5 [5]. Shortfalls are billed and credited to PG&E’s revenue requirement [5].
- Security and exit. Security equals five years of that obligation at full requested capacity; it steps down in years 12 through 15, and leaving early costs whatever security remains [5].
PG&E justifies the 80% figure with an E3 study that found “fewer than half had load factors above 80%” among data centers [5]. SCE’s ER27-508 uses the same formula with rates fixed for 15 years, and before service begins a customer that walks away owes the greater of 20% of estimated upgrade costs or the actual cost of abandoned facilities [6]. SCE says it is aligned with PG&E, SDG&E and LS Power on upfront security and exit fees, but that “uniformity in the PTOs’ tariffs should not be expected” [6].
Where the sides stand
Ratepayer advocates want CAISO to do more itself. The Public Advocates Office at the CPUC told CAISO in October that it “should not rely exclusively on the PTOs to prevent cost shifting” [8]. It warned that refunded payments end up in utility revenue requirements “paid for by all TAC ratepayers” [8]. It asked for a lower threshold, 20 MW instead of 50, saying loads just under the cutoff, some at 49 MW, carry over $1 billion in upgrade costs [8]. By its count, CAISO concurred with nearly $2 billion in upgrades for 11 large loads in the 2025-2026 plan, and PG&E has proposed over $2.5 billion for 13 more [8]. On FILI, it asked CAISO to quantify ratepayer savings “rather than treating accelerated large-load interconnection as a ratepayer benefit in itself” [8].
Data center developers pressed on process. Microsoft backed paying for upgrades “reasonably attributable” to its requests but asked for safeguards against “duplicative cost recovery or financial security requirements,” and for clearer FILI curtailment terms [9]. It suggested a map of grid locations that could take load without major upgrades [9].
Generators asked for dates. NextEra supported FILI but said CAISO’s proposal “does not identify when” permanent flexible service work will begin [10]. Constellation, citing the Thanksgiving holiday and linked issues, asked FERC to push the utility comment date from December 7 to December 16 [7].
CAISO says stakeholders “overwhelmingly support” its final proposal and asks FERC to end the show cause proceeding [1].
What I’m watching
- December 7 and 16: comments on PG&E and SCE, then CAISO [3,4]. Watch whether the Public Advocates Office takes the 20 MW threshold and the cost-shifting argument to FERC [8].
- February 16, 2027: the requested effective date [1].
CAISO concedes “there is little case law or Commission precedent” on just and reasonable rates for large loads, and says it will build a uniform rule if FERC asks for one [1]. Whether FERC accepts a cost answer written utility by utility is the open question.
Owen Hollis
Key dates
- Comments due on PG&E (ER27-513) and SCE (ER27-508) large load filings
- Comments due on CAISO's large load filing (ER27-532)
- Effective date requested by CAISO, PG&E and SCE
- Effective date CAISO requests for large load scheduling coordinator rules
Reader questions
Does a data center in California have to bring its own generation to connect to the CAISO grid?
No. CAISO's filing says a bring-your-own-generation requirement is not a condition for interconnection or transmission service, because supply is planned and procured through state resource planning and each load-serving entity's resource adequacy obligations [1].
What counts as a large load under CAISO's proposed tariff?
An end user at a single site behind one or more points of interconnection to the CAISO-controlled grid with a peak load of 50 MW or more [1]. Loads already operating, or with a complete request at the utility before February 16, 2027, are not covered unless they later expand [1].
What is PG&E's Minimum Annual Revenue Obligation for large loads?
It is a yearly floor equal to the scheduled megawatts times the hours in the year times 80% times 75% times the CAISO access charge; if the customer's actual transmission revenue falls short, PG&E bills the difference [5]. The customer posts security of five years of that floor at full requested capacity [5].
When are comments due on the California large load filings at FERC?
December 7, 2026 for PG&E (ER27-513) and SCE (ER27-508), and December 16, 2026 for CAISO's filing (ER27-532), per FERC's notices [3,4]. Constellation has asked FERC to move the utility deadline to December 16 [7].
What is Flexible Interim Load Interconnection (FILI)?
A CAISO option that lets a large load energize before its network upgrades are finished, subject to curtailment terms set in a three-party agreement with the utility, then switch to firm service when the upgrades are in service [1]. CAISO sets no time or size cap on it and plans to post the agreements publicly [1].
A note on sourcing
This column draws on the transmittal letters of CAISO, PG&E and SCE, not on the full redlined tariffs or pro forma agreements; where a letter and the tariff text differ, the tariff controls. San Diego Gas & Electric's companion filing (ER27-521) and the filings of the smaller transmission owners are not covered here. The Public Advocates Office, Microsoft and NextEra positions come from comments on CAISO's September 24 draft proposal, filed before the final tariff; none of the three had filed comments at FERC on these dockets in the record this column draws on. The Public Advocates Office's dollar figures for upgrades tied to large loads are its own reading of CAISO and PG&E planning documents. The data center load figures are California Energy Commission forecasts as quoted by CAISO and PG&E, which cite different horizons. FERC had not ruled on Constellation's request to move the December 7 comment date. None of the filings names a data center project or states a megawatt total of pending large-load requests.
Sources
- 1Large Loads Tariff Amendment and Response to Order to Show Cause (transmittal letter), Docket No. ER27-532-000California Independent System Operator Corporation · November 16, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 2Notice of Withdrawal of Filing and Termination of Proceeding in Deference to New Docket ER27-532-000, Docket No. ER27-506-000California Independent System Operator Corporation · November 18, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 3Combined Notice of Filings #1 (including Docket No. ER27-532-000)Federal Energy Regulatory Commission · November 18, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 4Combined Notice of Filings #1 (including Docket Nos. ER27-508-000 and ER27-513-000)Federal Energy Regulatory Commission · November 16, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 5Tariff Amendments in Response to FERC Order to Show Cause in Docket No. EL26-71-000 (transmittal letter), Docket No. ER27-513-000Pacific Gas and Electric Company · November 16, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 6SCE OSC - Large Load, TO Tariff Revisions (transmittal letter and attachments), Docket No. ER27-508-000Southern California Edison Company · November 16, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 7Expedited Motion for a Nine-Day Extension of Comment Deadline, Docket Nos. ER27-513-000, ER27-508-000 and ER27-521-000Constellation Energy Generation, LLC · November 19, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 8Comments on Large Loads Draft Final Proposal and 10/1 MeetingPublic Advocates Office at the California Public Utilities Commission · October 15, 2026 · stakeholdercenter.caiso.com
- 9Comments on Large Loads Draft Final Proposal and 10/1 MeetingMicrosoft · October 15, 2026 · stakeholdercenter.caiso.com
- 10Comments on Large Loads Draft Final Proposal and 10/1 MeetingNextEra Energy Resources · October 15, 2026 · stakeholdercenter.caiso.com
Filed under: California / large load interconnection / cost allocation / data centers / co-location / flexible interconnection