New York's Data Center Rules Reach FERC: Bring New Capacity or Go Non-Firm at $200, and Pay for Upgrades in 15 Years
In FERC Docket ER27-517, NYISO sorts large loads into firm and non-firm service by their effect on resource adequacy, with a state exemption. The utilities' companion filing, ER27-529, makes the load pay 100% of its upgrades over 15 years.
| Item | Body | Load | Stage | Src |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Large Load Integration Procedures, Firm and Non-Firm Withdrawal Service, $200/MWh non-firm bid cap | FERC Docket ER27-517 (NYISO) | applies to loads of 50 MW or more | filed Nov. 16, 2026; procedures requested effective Feb. 1, 2027; market rules June 1, 2028 | [1] |
| Large Load Cost Recovery Agreement (100% of allocated costs over 15 years), Security Agreement, Interconnection Agreement | FERC Docket ER27-529 (New York Transmission Owners) | — | filed Nov. 16, 2026; agreements requested effective May 1, 2028 | [2] |
| Large load requests in NYISO's interconnection queue | NYISO | over 12 GW as of March 2026 | queue requests, mostly entered in 2025 | [7] |
| Interconnection Reforms for Large Loads | New York PSC Case 26-E-0045 | — | pending since Feb. 12, 2026 | [5] |
Over 12 GW of large load requests sat in the New York ISO’s interconnection queue as of March 2026, most of them filed in 2025, by the count of NYISO’s market monitor [7]. In the past decade, about 500 MW of large load actually entered service in New York, mostly cryptocurrency mining [7]. On November 16, NYISO and the state’s six investor-owned transmission owners answered FERC’s June 18 show cause order with rules for sorting that queue: FERC Docket ER27-517 for the study process and new services, ER27-529 for who pays [1,2]. The two filings make a data center choose between bringing new capacity and accepting a non-firm connection, and then require it to pay for its upgrades within 15 years [1,2].
The test in ER27-517: firm if the grid can carry it
NYISO defines a Large Load as 50 MW or more at one site or “in close proximity,” meaning within 2 miles and 2 electrical buses and in the same Capacity Region [1]. Unlike FERC’s suggested definition, it includes co-located load [1].
Each project gets one of three outcomes [1]:
- Firm Withdrawal Service, with the same priority as firm point-to-point transmission, if the project does not harm resource adequacy or transmission security [1].
- Non-Firm Withdrawal Service for the share that does. That load must bid no higher than $200/MWh at its node, which is how NYISO curtails it [1].
- Zero withdrawal, for co-located loads that are not authorized to draw energy from the grid at all [1].
The resource adequacy test is where the sorting happens. NYISO models each project over years 1 through 10; a project that degrades resource adequacy by 25 MW or less gets its full request as firm service [1]. Above that, the firm share is cut until the loss-of-load expectation returns to its pre-project level [1]. A project can win back firm service by pairing with a new capacity resource, either co-located at its point of interconnection or elsewhere in its Capacity Region, under an arrangement that must last 15 years [1]. Until that pairing is certified, the load is non-firm [1].
NYISO’s reason is its own planning. Its July informational report said preliminary results could show a statewide resource adequacy violation first occurring in 2033 and growing through 2036 to a deficiency greater than 1,800 MW when forecasted large load growth is counted [8].
What it does to cost and timing
Fees. A $10,000 application fee; a study deposit of $100,000, $150,000 or $200,000 depending on size; and a readiness deposit of $4,000 per MW of peak load before the final assessment [1]. Non-firm and zero-withdrawal loads also pay a System Reliability Benefit Fee, a capacity market charge based on the megawatts NYISO authorizes rather than energy consumed [1].
Time. NYISO asks for a February 1, 2027 effective date, when its current load queue is withdrawn except for projects that have finished their studies or qualify for two transition groups [1]. A transition cycle starts June 1, 2027 and the first regular cycle July 1, 2027 [1]. Each cycle takes between about a year and a half and two years [1]. NYISO concedes that this “is longer than the process duration contemplated by the Show Cause Order,” which suggested 60 to 90 days [1]. The transmission owners do not expect the first facilities studies to finish until the third quarter of 2028 [2].
Upgrades: the owners’ half. In ER27-529, Central Hudson, Con Edison, NYSEG, National Grid, Orange and Rockland and RG&E propose a cost recovery agreement under which each owner recovers 100% of the network upgrade and attachment facility costs allocated to a large load [2]. Many upgrades last 40 years or longer, the owners note, and a contract that long multiplies collateral risk [2]. So they take the yearly revenue requirement, multiply it by the asset’s average service life and divide by 15 [2]. The load pays the whole cost in 15 years while the utility depreciates the asset normally; starting in year 16, the utility credits the deferred excess back to the cost of service in its rates, so other customers are not charged for the upgrade [2]. Security is cash or a letter of credit, reset each year to cover what remains [2]. The owners propose no new delivery rates, leaving those to the New York PSC [2].
Readers of yesterday’s column on PJM will see the contrast. PJM’s owners proposed a minimum of 80% to 100% of a benchmark and a handoff of remaining upgrade costs to the region after year 15. New York’s owners run the money the other way after year 15 [2].
Where the sides stand
New York regulators set the boundary early. In July, the New York PSC told FERC that it “is the primary entity responsible for ensuring the adequacy of generation resources in New York,” and pointed to its own large load proceeding, Case 26-E-0045, opened in February [5]. NYISO’s answer is the State Exempt Large Load Project: the Department of Public Service can designate projects that are tested as a group against the state reliability criterion over years 1 through 5 instead of one by one, and can revoke designations within 60 days if the group fails [1]. That rule was added after an October 21 committee meeting [1]. At the October 28 vote, the department’s Adam Evans said “we do not object to your 205-proposal moving forward,” while reserving “the right to raise issues” at FERC [6]. The Management Committee approved the package by a 100% vote with abstentions [1].
The market monitor asked for much of this structure. Potomac Economics wrote that most large loads in the queue “have indicated that they do not intend to build new on-site generation or operate flexibly” during peaks [7]. It recommended that studies distinguish firm from non-firm load, that non-firm load get faster timelines and lower costs, and that generation for large loads come from “contracting by loads or merchant entry, not cost-of-service contracts” [7]. NYISO’s filing adopts the firm and non-firm split [1].
Flexible-load developers objected to the price trigger, as NYISO describes it. Some stakeholders said a single $200/MWh cap was too low and too rigid when winter fuel costs run high, and could sit below a load’s true cost of curtailment [1]. NYISO replied that fuel indexing is not feasible on this schedule and that caps of $1,000 or $2,000 would push curtailments outside the market software [1]. No developer had filed its own argument with FERC in the record this column draws on.
Existing on-site generation loses a program. NYISO would close its behind-the-meter net generation program to new enrollment on February 1, 2027 and end it May 1, 2029; it has six active resources [1].
What I’m watching
- December 14: comments on ER27-517 [3]. FERC’s notice lists December 7 for ER27-529 [4]. Watch whether the PSC or Department of Public Service contest the 25 MW test, and whether developers press for a different $200 trigger [1,6].
- Case 26-E-0045: the state exemption only works once the PSC adopts a process for granting it, and the owners set their agreements’ effective date at May 1, 2028 to give that proceeding time [1,2].
What the filings do not say is how much of the 12 GW would come through as firm [7]. That answer starts with the first resource adequacy evaluations once the study cycles open in June and July 2027 [1].
Owen Hollis
Key dates
- Comment date in FERC's notice for the transmission owners' filing (ER27-529)
- Comments due on NYISO's filing (ER27-517)
- Effective date NYISO requests for the new procedures; existing load queue withdrawn except transition projects
- Transition study cycle begins
- First regular large load study cycle begins
- Effective date requested for the cost recovery, security and interconnection agreements
Reader questions
When are comments due on NYISO's large load filing at FERC?
Comments on NYISO's filing, Docket ER27-517, are due at 5 p.m. Eastern on December 14, 2026, after FERC corrected its notice [3]. FERC's notice lists December 7, 2026 for the transmission owners' companion filing, ER27-529 [4].
What happens to a New York data center that would strain resource adequacy?
If a project degrades statewide resource adequacy by more than 25 MW, NYISO limits it to partial firm service unless it pairs with new capacity under a 15-year arrangement; the remainder is non-firm [1]. Non-firm load must bid no higher than $200/MWh at its node, so it is curtailed when prices reach that level [1].
Who pays for transmission upgrades for data centers in New York under the new proposal?
The transmission owners propose that the large load customer pay 100% of the network upgrade and attachment facility costs allocated to it, compressed into a 15-year term [2]. From year 16, the utility credits the excess it collected back to other customers' rates [2].
When could a data center apply under NYISO's new large load process?
NYISO asked for a February 1, 2027 effective date, a transition study cycle starting June 1, 2027 and the first regular cycle on July 1, 2027 [1]. The transmission owners do not expect the first facilities studies to finish until the third quarter of 2028 [2].
What is a State Exempt Large Load Project in New York?
It is a project the New York Department of Public Service identifies through the state's large load proceeding; such projects are tested together and get full firm service as long as their combined effect does not violate the state's resource adequacy criterion in years 1 through 5 [1]. The department can revoke the designation within 60 days of a NYISO notice of a violation [1].
A note on sourcing
This column draws on the transmittal letters of NYISO and the New York Transmission Owners, not on the full tariff sheets, affidavits or pro forma agreements; where the letters and tariff text differ, the tariff text controls. The 12 GW queue figure is the market monitor's, as of March 2026, and counts requests, not projects that will be built. The 1,800 MW deficiency is from preliminary planning results NYISO described in July and could change. Arguments that the $200/MWh cap is too low are reported as NYISO characterized them; the stakeholders who made them are not named in the filing. No data center developer, the Data Center Coalition or consumer advocates had filed a position on either filing in the record this column draws on; the Electric Power Supply Association has moved to intervene in both dockets without comment so far. New York's Department of Public Service reserved the right to raise issues at FERC. FERC's November 18 notice lists December 7 as the comment date for ER27-529; the December 14 extension applies by its terms to ER27-517.
Sources
- 1Proposed Tariff Revisions to Establish New Large Load Integration Procedures and Related Market Participation Provisions (transmittal letter), Docket No. ER27-517-000New York Independent System Operator, Inc. · November 16, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 2Section 205 Filing in Response to the Large Load Show Cause Order (transmittal letter), Docket No. ER27-529-000New York Transmission Owners · November 16, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 3Errata Notice Extending Comment Period, Docket No. ER27-517-000Federal Energy Regulatory Commission · November 18, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 4Combined Notice of Filings #1 (including Docket No. ER27-529-000)Federal Energy Regulatory Commission · November 18, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 5Notice of Intervention and Preliminary Comments of the New York State Public Service Commission, Docket No. EL26-69-000New York State Public Service Commission · July 9, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 6Adam Evans (DPS) Statement at the October 28 NYISO Management CommitteeNew York State Department of Public Service · October 28, 2026 · nyiso.com
- 72025 State of the Market Report for the NYISO Markets, excerpt: Critique of Large Load Interconnection ProcessPotomac Economics (NYISO Market Monitoring Unit) · accessed 2026-11-19 · nysrc.org
- 8Informational Report in compliance with the June 18, 2026 Order, Docket No. EL26-69-000New York Independent System Operator, Inc. · July 20, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
Filed under: New York / large load interconnection / cost allocation / data centers / non-firm service / resource adequacy