ATC's $914.5 Million for Microsoft's Racine Campus: Better Collateral, Same Fight Over Who Pays After Year 15
In FERC Docket ER26-3265, American Transmission Company rewrote its exit fee and security for the We Energies line work serving Microsoft. We Energies says that settles it; the Citizens Utility Board says the cost allocation is unchanged, and Microsoft still wants a settlement judge.
| Item | Body | Load | Stage | Src |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Four amended Large Load Project Commitment Agreements (MISO SAs 4200, 4201, 4202, 4205) | FERC Docket ER26-3265 (ATC and We Energies) | — | substitute versions filed Oct. 22, 2026; pending | [3] |
| Minimum Transmission Charge Agreement (MISO SA 4810) | FERC Docket ER26-3265 | capacity schedule filed as privileged | substitute filed Oct. 22, 2026; protested | [3] |
| Affiliated-interest approvals of the agreements | Public Service Commission of Wisconsin, Dockets 5-AE-246 and 5-AE-284 | — | pending as of Oct. 22, 2026 | [3] |
| We Energies Very Large Customer tariff | Public Service Commission of Wisconsin, Docket 6630-TE-113 | — | approved May 21, 2026 | [5] |
If a data center campus never draws the power its utility asked the grid to carry, who pays for the wires? In Wisconsin the wires already have a price: $914.5 million of transmission for a Microsoft data center campus in Racine County, by American Transmission Company’s estimate, one area of it already in service [3]. Last Thursday was the deadline for comments on ATC’s rewritten answer, in FERC Docket ER26-3265-001 [4]. We Energies says the rewrite settles the question [5]. The Citizens Utility Board of Wisconsin says it settles the easier half [6].
What ATC and We Energies put in front of FERC
ATC is a transmission-only company; MISO filed for it on July 24 [1]. The filing pairs two kinds of contract with Wisconsin Electric Power Company, which does business as We Energies [1]:
- Four amended Large Load Project Commitment Agreements (MISO Service Agreements 4200, 4201, 4202 and 4205), first accepted by FERC in 2024 in Dockets ER24-515 and ER24-1428. The amendments add a monthly CWIP Charge, meaning We Energies pays ATC’s return and taxes on construction work in progress while the lines are being built, and keep the duty to reimburse ATC if the project is cancelled [1].
- A Minimum Transmission Charge Agreement (Service Agreement 4810). After the facilities enter service, We Energies pays the network rate on 100% of its Requested Transmission Capacity, whether or not the campus uses it, for 15 years after the last facilities go in service [1].
The trigger is ATC’s Large Load Cost Allocation Business Practice, which applies to a new load of 100 MW or more at one site, or one that needs more than $100 million of transmission [1]. ATC pitched the package as a response to FERC’s June show cause order on MISO’s tariff, 195 FERC ¶ 61,212, the same proceeding that produced MISO’s own answer, the LARS paired-generation process, which this column covered on October 23 [1].
FERC staff found the July filing deficient on September 22. Cross-references pointed to sections that did not exist, and staff asked how the cap was built, why 15 years, and what supported the security schedule [2].
What the October rewrite changed
ATC’s October 22 response put numbers on the table [3]:
| Project area | Estimated capital cost |
|---|---|
| 2A | $305,000,000 |
| 2B | $195,000,000 |
| 3A | $82,000,000 |
| 3B (already in service) | $187,502,777 |
| Western Feed | $145,000,000 |
| Total | $914,502,777 |
The four areas under the pending agreements come to $727 million, the figure ATC used in its September answer [8]. Run through ATC’s 2027 formula rate inputs, a 7.74% weighted return that includes a 10.48% return on equity, and an assumed 37-year average depreciable life, the project’s revenue requirement totals $2,306,758,830 [3]. That total is the liability cap: once We Energies’ ordinary network charges plus any minimum charges reach it, the minimum charge stops [3].
Two terms moved. The early termination fee had been the requested capacity times the network rate for the rest of the term; it is now the project’s remaining net book value [3]. The security We Energies posts follows the same declining net book value, with a tax gross-up factor of 1.1275 [3]. Because net book value always sits below the cap, ATC says, neither is subject to it any longer [3].
The megawatts stay under seal. The Requested Transmission Capacity Schedule, the number every minimum charge is multiplied against, is marked privileged [3]. The public filing says $914.5 million. It does not say how many megawatts that buys.
Where the sides stand
We Energies wants the package accepted as filed, effective July 1. Without it, the utility says, “hundreds of millions of dollars” of investment, including over $39 million in financing costs, would land on ATC’s other customers [5]. It argues FERC “need not find the Agreements to be the best solution,” only a reasonable one, and that the 15-year term mirrors the Very Large Customer tariff the Wisconsin commission approved on May 21 in Docket 6630-TE-113 [5].
The Citizens Utility Board backs the net-book-value change and little else. “But better collateral is not better cost allocation,” its November 12 comments say [6]. Its objection is that ATC counts the ordinary network charges We Energies pays toward a cap meant to cover project-specific cost, so one obligation is credited against the other [6]. And it found a gap in ATC’s own table: the term is justified by a roughly 30-year useful life, the cap math assumes 37 years, and about $542.8 million of net plant remains after year 15 [6]. CUB asks FERC not to accept on this record, or to condition acceptance, or to send the case to settlement [6].
Microsoft, the customer the lines are for, is not a party to either agreement. In August it protested that ATC and We Energies, which it calls “two affiliated entities,” wrote the terms without its input [7]. It wants the minimum charge priced on the revenue requirement of the new facilities rather than ATC’s rolled-in network rate, and warned that large loads “may pay twice” if network charges keep running after the term [7]. It cites its signature on the White House Ratepayer Protection Pledge to pay for “all new power delivery infrastructure upgrades required to service [its] data centers” [7].
ATC answered that Microsoft, as a non-party, cannot renegotiate a bilateral contract, and that anything passed to Microsoft is the Wisconsin commission’s business under the retail tariff [8]. On paying twice, ATC says We Energies pays for network service like any other customer for as long as it uses the system [8]. It also accused Microsoft of trying “to build into the MTCA its own project development flexibility” [8].
The Public Service Commission of Wisconsin supported acceptance in August as “directionally appropriate” but took no position on the minimum charge agreement [9]. Its larger complaint is with ATC’s zonal rates. In its retail case, an analysis of an actual prospective very large customer showed a $441 million shift to ATC’s other wholesale customers over 45 years, in net present value, when that customer paid zonal rates rather than its direct costs [9]. The commission also said the four projects in the agreements do not match the eight MISO identified in 2024 expedited reviews for this load [9]. “‘Speed to Power’ must not be used as an excuse to turn a blind eye to cost causation principles,” it wrote [9].
What I’m watching
- FERC’s order in ER26-3265, which has no set date. The question is whether FERC accepts, conditions, or sends the agreements to a settlement judge as Microsoft and CUB ask [6,7]. If accepted, ATC would bill the CWIP Charge back to July 1, 2026 once Wisconsin approves the affiliate agreements in Dockets 5-AE-246 and 5-AE-284 [3].
- Whether Microsoft answers the substitute agreements. Its August protest was aimed at the July version; the exit-fee change answered part of it [3,7].
ATC’s cap schedule runs 37 years [3]. The agreement runs 15 after the last line energizes [1]. Who carries the $542.8 million in between is the question nobody’s filing has yet answered [6].
Owen Hollis
Key dates
- Effective date ATC requests for the agreements and the CWIP Charge
- Comment date on ATC's deficiency response (ER26-3265-001)
Reader questions
How much transmission is ATC building to serve Microsoft's Racine County data center campus?
American Transmission Company estimates $914.5 million in initial capital costs across five project areas, one of which, Area 3B at about $187.5 million, is already in service [3]. The four areas covered by the pending agreements total $727 million [8].
Does We Energies have to pay for the transmission if Microsoft uses less power than requested?
Under the proposed Minimum Transmission Charge Agreement, yes: We Energies pays the network rate on 100% of its requested capacity for 15 years after the last facilities enter service, up to a cap of about $2.307 billion [1,3]. Its contracts with the end-use customer are meant to pass those charges through [1].
What did ATC change in its October 22 deficiency response?
The early termination fee and the security requirement now equal the project's remaining net book value, including tax gross-up, rather than the network rate times capacity for the rest of the term [3]. ATC also fixed broken cross-references FERC staff found in the agreements [2,3].
Is Microsoft a party to the ATC transmission agreements?
No. The agreements are between ATC and We Energies, and ATC argues that any costs passed to Microsoft belong before the Wisconsin commission under We Energies' Very Large Customer tariff [8]. Microsoft has asked FERC for hearing and settlement judge procedures, or rejection without prejudice [7].
When will FERC rule on ATC's large-load agreements in ER26-3265?
No order date is set in the record; comments on the substitute agreements were due November 12, 2026 [4]. ATC asks for a July 1, 2026 effective date and plans catch-up construction-financing billing to that date once Wisconsin approves the affiliate agreements [3].
A note on sourcing
This column draws on the transmittal letters, FERC staff's deficiency letter and the parties' pleadings; it does not draw on the agreements' full text or the non-public version of the Minimum Transmission Charge Agreement. The Requested Transmission Capacity Schedule, which sets the megawatts We Energies would pay for, is marked privileged, so no megawatt figure for the Microsoft campus appears in the public record. The $914.5 million capital figure and the $2.307 billion liability cap are American Transmission Company's estimates and will change as actual costs come in. The $441 million figure is the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin's net-present-value estimate from its retail tariff case, as described in its FERC comments. Microsoft and the Data Center Coalition had not filed on the October 22 substitute agreements by the November 12 comment date, in the record this column draws on. FERC has set no date for an order, and the Wisconsin commission's affiliated-interest reviews (Dockets 5-AE-246 and 5-AE-284) were still pending as of October 22.
Sources
- 1Amended Large Load Project Commitment Agreements and Minimum Transmission Charge Agreement, Docket No. ER26-3265-000 (transmittal letter)American Transmission Company LLC · July 24, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 2Deficiency Letter, Docket No. ER26-3265-000Federal Energy Regulatory Commission · September 22, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 3Response to Deficiency Letter, Docket No. ER26-3265-001American Transmission Company LLC · October 22, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 4Combined Notice of Filings #2, October 22, 2026 (ER26-3265-001)Federal Energy Regulatory Commission · October 22, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 5Comments of Wisconsin Electric Power Company, Docket No. ER26-3265-001Wisconsin Electric Power Company · November 12, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 6Supplemental Comments of the Citizens Utility Board of Wisconsin, Docket No. ER26-3265Citizens Utility Board of Wisconsin · November 12, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 7Protest and Motion for Hearing and Settlement Judge Procedures of Microsoft Corporation, Docket No. ER26-3265-000Microsoft Corporation · August 21, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 8Motion for Leave to Answer and Answer of American Transmission Company LLC, Docket No. ER26-3265-000American Transmission Company LLC · September 8, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
- 9Comments of the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin, Docket No. ER26-3265Public Service Commission of Wisconsin · August 14, 2026 · elibrary.ferc.gov
Filed under: American Transmission Company / We Energies / Microsoft / Wisconsin / cost allocation / data centers